Showing posts with label finance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label finance. Show all posts

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Money Management Software

It turns out that I am pretty tired of Quicken. It seems to be a bit buggy and the amount of advertising in it is really annoying. Plus I have been using the Windows version and hear that the Mac version stinks. Even if I wanted to switch there is no good way to convert from Windows to Mac (Intuit provides a tool but basically says "Use at your own risk -- we didn't design these to convert back and forth."). So I am stuck with Quicken for Windows in a Parallels session (which is nice and all but it's slow and clunky).

As a result every few months I think I'll try Wesabe, or Mint, or Yodlee, or Morningstar. But I always back down and then forget most of what I have learned in doing the research. Keep in mind I haven't used any of these sites--this isn't a review--just some notes to myself about what I have learned about each site. So here goes:

Wesabe:
Tim O'Reilly is an investor and backer which makes me like it from the get go. They are crazy about security and data rights -- their philosophy is that you own your own data. They don't take account numbers or user names or anything. Instead of automatic updates of account information it is semi-automatic. They provide uploader tools so that you can download info from your bank to your own computer and then upload it to Wesabe. This means that all they have is a pile of data -- no way to access your accounts.

The focus of the site seems to be on managing spending and saving -- tracking cash flow. They claim to have nifty reports and so forth and let you compare your habits to other people. They can help you by providing a community to work on spending goals (or savings goals).

The big downside is they do nothing to track investments, zip, zilch, nada so they don't really meet my needs.

Mint:
They claim to do both cash flow and investment analysis. You provide account login information when you sign up and then they automatically retrieve transactions from your financial insitutions. The rub here is that they claim they don't store any of this stuff (username, passwords, etc). Which, I guess, is, technically speaking, true because they use yodlee for this (see entry below). But it means that all of your passwords and login info is stored in a single place on the web. They also claim that Mint is "read-only" so nobody could mess with your accounts even if they broke into your mint account. I guess this is also true. But the credintials that are stored by yodlee are the same ones that you use to log in to the banks' websites so again all of your info is out there in one place as best I can figure.

Seems like it might be worth trying if I wasn't paranoid about having all of my username/passwords in the hands of a single website.

Yodlee:
Based on the look of their website they got their start as a financial aggregator not a consumer website. They offer a personal money management page but it does not appear to be their primary business.

You provide yodlee with all of your usernames and passwords and they periodically log in to your financial institutions and get updated account information. They also make some mention of managing money all in one spot so it may be that they can initiate transactions from their website.

Like Mint they claim to show you investment accounts too.

Morningstar:
Focused entirely on investments. They provide no cash flow or budgeting tools. They also provide no tools for automatically updating accounts -- you have to enter all transactions by hand and there doesn't seem to be an uploader. Finally there is a monthly cost to use the service. On the other hand they are the industry leader in providing investment information and the tools do seem to be pretty useful (I signed up for one of their free 14 day trials and put in some fake data to try things out.)

That's all I can think of for the moment. See you in a month when you get sick of Quicken (again).

Sunday, May 4, 2008

asset allocation vs asset diversification

Work just changed our 401k options and has made lifecycle funds the default contribution. They also took away Asset Allocation funds (Conservative, Moderate, Aggressive) and replaced them with Lifecycle funds. So I am thinking about what the right strategy is and how to do the transition. There doesn't seem to be much information on how to handle single events. Everyone says that allocation is important and that you should re-allocate periodically but doesn't give any advice on the nuts and bolts of doing so. There isn't anything that says "I have decided to change my strategy here's some things to consider". I get that I can't know for sure what will happen over the next few months but all of the sources that I have found don't seem to say anything about what do differently if you assume that the market (and the US economy as a whole) is generally doing well or generally doing poorly. I realize that the whole point of long term investing is that you need to find a strategy and stick to it but given that I have a whole bunch more information about what is going on this month and this year should I make different tactical decisions about how to implement the strategy?

Anyhow that lead me to flip through Living and Learning by Robert Keebler and Daniel Pinkerton and something struck me which I hadn't grasped before. They make a distinction between asset allocation and asset diversification. They define asset allocation as the choice of which asset classes to own and define 4 asset classes: cash equivalents, fixed-income investments, equity investments (including real estate), and tangibles (precious metals, commodities, collectibles). They define asset diversification as the selection of investments within those asset classes. This is a slightly different way to slice things than what Quicken presents. Quicken gives 7 asset classes (8 if you count no class) that divide Keebler and Pinkerton's classes further by separating equities into US Large Cap, US Small Cap, and International Stocks and fixed income into US and Global Bonds. It gets to the same point I suppose but the way Living and Learning presented made it simpler to me.